Document Type : Original Article
Research Article
Seed priming enhances sugar beet resistance to beet curly tip Iran virus
Marziyeh Koushki, Roya Kazemi, Naser Safaie, Mohammad Reza Atighi and Masoud Shams-Bakhsh*
Department of Plant Pathology, Faculty of Agriculture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract: This study assessed the effects of seed treatment with Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) on sugar beet genotypes on growth, physiological characteristics, and responses to beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV; Becurtovirus betae) infection. Two sugar beet genotypes, SB23 and 980043, were subjected to microbial and chemical seed priming, followed by agroinoculation with BCTIV under greenhouse conditions. Primed plants showed significantly lower symptom severity and higher BCTIV accumulation than non-primed controls (P < 0.05). Growth parameters, including shoot and root fresh and dry weights, chlorophyll and carotenoid contents, leaf area index, and plant height, were significantly enhanced in primed plants. Antioxidant enzyme activities, including polyphenol oxidase (PPO), peroxidase (POX), and catalase (CAT), were significantly elevated in primed plants, indicating activation of systemic defense responses. Treatments effectively reduced BCTIV impact by increasing resistance, which is associated with stronger biochemical defense responses and improved physiological status. These findings indicate that seed treatment with B. subtilis, T. zelobreve, and BABA promotes sugar beet growth, enhances antioxidant defense responses, and reduces BCTIV accumulation, representing a promising and sustainable strategy for disease management in affected areas.
Keywords: BCTIV accumulation, antioxidant enzyme activity, seed priming, quantitative PCR
Sugar beet is susceptible to various pathogens, including fungal, bacterial, viral, and nematode pathogens. Among these, beet mosaic disease, beet rhizomania, and beet curly top disease are the most important. The primary causative agent of beet curly top disease, which affects sugar beet and several other dicotyledonous plants in Iran, is the beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV; Becurtovirus betae). This disease severely reduces sugar beet yields, especially in arid and semi-arid regions (Yıldırım et al., 2022). BCTIV belongs to the family Geminiviridae, which is divided into 15 genera based on characteristics such as host range, genomic organization, sequence identity, number of genomic components, and insect vector (Roumagnac et al., 2022). The disease was first reported in Iran in 1967 (Gibson, 1967) and affects more than 300 species across 44 plant families, including crops, ornamental plants, and weeds (Bennett, 1971).
Beet curly top disease in Iran is caused by beet curly top virus-Severe (BCTV-Svr; Curtovirus betae), beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV; Becurtovirus betae), sesame curly top virus (STCV; Turncurtovirus sesami) (Hasanvand et al., 2018), turnip curly top virus (TCuCV; Turncurtovirus brassicae) (Varsani et al., 2014), and turnip leaf roll virus (TLRV; Turncurtovirus rapae) (Kamali et al., 2016; Heydarnejad et al., 2007; Yazdi et al., 2008). Recently, BCTIV (Becurtovirus betae) has also been reported in Turkey, indicating its geographical expansion beyond Iran (Yıldırım et al., 2022). BCTIV is naturally transmitted by insects in a persistent non-propagative manner (Kamali et al., 2016; Varsani et al., 2014). The leafhopper Circulifer haemataceps is the vector of BCTIV in sugar beet fields in Iran (Taheri et al., 2012; Fatahi et al., 2012). Disease symptoms include stunted growth, interveinal chlorosis, leaf curling, and vein swelling (Heydarnejad et al., 2007; Strausbaugh et al., 2008Yıldırım et al., 2022).
Various strategies manage plant diseases. Among these, chemical priming and biopriming of seeds have gained attention as eco-friendly approaches that enhance plants’ capacity to rapidly and robustly activate immune responses upon pathogen challenge. Biopriming with Trichoderma harzianum has reduced the incidence of BCTV-Svr in sugar beet by increasing peroxidase and polyphenol oxidase activities in primed plants compared with controls (Mafakheri et al., 2024). In addition, application of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens (Ba13) to tomato seedlings increased expression of systemic resistance-related genes (PR1, PR2, PR3) and activities of defense enzymes (phenylalanine ammonia lyase, polyphenol oxidase, peroxidase, β-1,3-glucanase, and chitinase), which led to the suppression of tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV) by decreasing the infection rate, disease severity, and virus accumulation (Guo et al., 2019).
Seed treatments with Bacillus subtilis followed by spraying the bacterial suspension onto tomato seedlings also reduced TYLCV severity by increasing peroxidase activity (Ghanem and Aqil, 2021). Similarly, lipopeptides from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens, including NPR1 and PR8 (chitinase), induce systemic resistance genes in sugar beet roots, which is associated with reduced infectivity of Polymyxa betae, the rhizome vector (Desoignies et al., 2013). Other examples of chemical defense inducers include the disease-suppressing effects of β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) seed treatment (Baccelli and Mauch-Mani, 2016). BABA seed treatment in sugar beet reduces susceptibility to BCTV-Svr, with lowered virus accumulation as measured by qPCR (Mafakheri et al., 2024). Similar results have been obtained in zucchini seeds soaked in 1% BABA (Rashid, 2014) and in tomato seeds treated with BABA to inhibit tomato mosaic virus spots on tomato (Khazir and Jarjis, 2012).
Seed treatments with beneficial fungi, antagonistic or symbiotic bacteria, and chemical inducers like BABA offer promising, sustainable disease management strategies by protecting vulnerable seedling stages and promoting germination and growth (Kazemi et al., 2026a).
This study aims to evaluate the impact of seed treatment with B. subtilis, T. zelobreve, and BABA on growth parameters, physiological traits, and defense-response activation in sugar beet plants challenged with BCTIV. Although these treatments have shown promise against other plant pathogens, their effectiveness against BCTIV in sugar beet has not yet been explored; this study addresses that gap.
Materials and Methods
Plant material and growth conditions
Two sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) genotypes, coded SB23 and 980043, were obtained from the Sugar Beet Seed Institute, Karaj, Iran. Seedlings were grown in an insect-proof greenhouse at 25 ± 2 °C with a 16-hour light/8-hour dark photoperiod during autumn and winter under natural light conditions. The experiments were conducted as a factorial experiment (2 genotypes × 4 priming treatments × 2 virus inoculation levels) in a completely randomized layout with 31 replicates per treatment; each experiment was independently repeated twice to ensure reproducibility.
Experimental treatments
Plants were assigned to eight treatment groups: seeds treated with either T. zelobreve (109 CFU/ml), β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) (10 mM), or B. subtilis (108 CFU/ml), each with virus-inoculated and non-inoculated subgroups, along with two control groups: non-treated, non-inoculated (Control) and virus-inoculated only (V).
Seed treatment procedures
Preparation and application of B. subtilis
A fresh culture of B. subtilis was grown in Luria-Bertani (LB) broth for 24 hours at 28 °C with agitation at 160 rpm. Subsequently, 1 mL of this culture was inoculated into 100 mL of fresh LB medium and incubated for an additional 4 hours to reach approximately 108 CFU/ml. The bacterial cells were harvested by centrifugation at 6000 rpm for 15 minutes at room temperature; the bacterial pellet was resuspended in sterile distilled water to obtain a homogeneous cell suspension, and finally resuspended in 1% (w/v) carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) to prepare a bacterial suspension of 108 CFU/mL for seed coating. Sugar beet seeds were soaked in sterile water for 3 hours, surface-sterilized with 1% sodium hypochlorite for 1 minute, rinsed thoroughly with sterile distilled water, and soaked in the bacterial suspension with shaking at 150 rpm for 3 hours at room temperature. Seeds were then air-dried overnight in a laminar flow hood before sowing (Kazemi et al., 2026b).
Preparation and application of T. zelobreve
Wheat grains were boiled for 25-30 minutes to soften and sterilized by autoclaving twice at 121 °C for 20 minutes with a 24-hour interval. Each jar was filled with approximately 80 g of dry wheat (140 g after soaking), inoculated with ~0.5 cm agar plugs containing T. zelobreve, and incubated at 30 °C for 4-5 days with intermittent shaking to prevent clumping and ensure aeration. Spores were washed off with 120 mL sterile distilled water and centrifuged twice as above, resuspending the pellet in 1% CMC to obtain a 109 CFU/mL spore suspension. Surface-sterilized sugar beet seeds were soaked in this suspension with shaking (150 rpm) for 3 hours at room temperature and dried overnight under sterile conditions before planting (Kazemi et al., 2026b).
Preparation and application of β-Aminobutyric Acid (BABA)
A 10 mM BABA solution was freshly prepared in sterile distilled water. Seed treatment followed the protocol described above for bacterial and fungal treatments: seeds were soaked in BABA solution for 3 hours with gentle shaking at room temperature, then dried under sterile airflow before sowing.
Virus inoculation
Sugar beet plants were agroinoculated with an infectious clone of beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV) (GenBank accession no. JQ707949) as described by Heydarnejad et al. (2013). Agroinoculation was conducted using Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain LBA4404 carrying infectious clones of BCTIV. The bacterial culture was grown in liquid LB medium supplemented with kanamycin (50 μg/ml) and rifampicin (50 μg/ml). As a control, a separate group of plants was agroinfiltrated with A. tumefaciens LBA4404 carrying the empty vector under the same conditions. Cultures were incubated at 180 rpm until the optical density at 600 nm (OD600) reached 0.2–0.6 (Grimsley et al., 1986). The cells were subsequently harvested by centrifugation at 6000 rpm for 10 minutes and resuspended in sterile distilled water containing 50 mM acetosyringone. Agroinoculation was carried out by leaf infiltration at the four- to six-leaf stage, approximately 40 days after sowing (Sedano et al., 2012). Symptom development was monitored (Montazeri et al., 2016; Kazemi et al., 2025a).
DNA extraction and Quantitative PCR (qPCR) analysis
Leaf tissue samples, all leaves except the virus-inoculated leaf, were collected at 40 days post-inoculation (dpi). DNA was extracted using the CTAB method as described by Doyle and Doyle (1987).
Virus accumulation in plant tissues was quantified by qPCR using primers targeting a 127 bp segment of BCTIV (Table S1). qPCR was performed using RealQ SYBR Green PCR master mix (Amplicon, Denmark) and an ABI StepOne Real-Time PCR System (Applied Biosystems, USA). Reactions included four biological replicates (each a pooled sample of five plants) and two technical replicates per biological replicate. Relative quantification was calculated using the 2-ΔΔCT method, normalized against the sugar beet small subunit (SSU) rDNA gene (Livak and Schmittgen 2001).
For each sample, ΔCt = Ct (virus) – Ct (SSU).
ΔΔCt = ΔCt (sample) – mean ΔCt (virus-only control).
Fold change = 2 –ΔΔCt
Growth parameter measurements
At 40 dpi, plants were harvested to measure the fresh weight of shoots and roots. Samples were then oven-dried at 70 °C for 48 hours to determine dry weight.
Enzyme activity assays
Activities of polyphenol oxidase (PPO), peroxidase (POX), and catalase (CAT) were determined at 2, 4, and 40 days post-inoculation (dpi) to evaluate both early and late biochemical responses induced by BCTIV infection and seed priming treatments. The PPO and POX activities were assayed according to the method described by Siguemoto and Gut (2017), based on absorbance measurements at 420 and 470 nm, respectively. CAT activity was determined following the method of Maehly and Chance (1954) by measuring absorbance at 240 nm. All enzyme assays were performed using a microplate reader (Epoch BioTek, USA). Leaf samples (all leaves except the virus-inoculated leaf) were collected, and 100 mg of tissue was homogenized in appropriate extraction buffers. Each enzymatic assay was performed using four biological replicates with two technical replicates.
Chlorophyll and carotenoid content
Chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, and total carotenoid contents were quantified spectrophotometrically at 665, 652, and 470 nm, respectively, using the method of (Warren, 2008). Additionally, leaf greenness was assessed in vivo using a SPAD chlorophyll meter.
Assessment of rhizosphere microbial population dynamics
Rhizosphere soil samples were collected at 5 and 11 weeks after planting to evaluate the population dynamics of B. subtilis and T. zelobreve. Ten grams of soil per sample were suspended in 50 mL of sterile distilled water, serially diluted, and plated in duplicate on Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA) for fungal counts and Luria-Bertani (LB) agar for bacterial counts. Colony-forming units (CFUs) were counted after incubation (Fig. S1) (Mafakheri et al., 2024).
Root colonization assessment
Root colonization by B. subtilis and T. zelobreve was verified using modified root segment plating and staining methods (Phillips and Hayman, 1970). At 5 and 11 weeks post-planting, eight root segments per plant were surface sterilized (70% ethanol and 96% alcohol washes), dried, and plated on PDA amended with ampicillin (for T. zelobreve) or LB plates (for B. subtilis), and incubated at 28 °C. Colonization percentages were calculated based on the number of segments showing microbial growth relative to the total segments )Fig. S2).
Statistical analysis
All quantitative data were analyzed using SAS 9.2 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC). ANOVA was performed with the GLM procedure, and residual normality was checked using the UNIVARIATE procedure. Severity data, as ordinal data, were rank-transformed and analyzed using the nonparametric methods outlined by Shah and Madden (2004). Mean separations were conducted via LSD tests at P ≤ 0.05. This analysis revealed no significant differences between the experiments, justifying pooling the data for final evaluation. Composite analysis was performed with Minitab 18.1.
Results
Primed plants exhibited lower symptom severity of BCTIV
Symptom severity was assessed 40 days after inoculation. The virus-only (V) treatment and B. subtilis (BS)-treated plants of the SB23 genotypes, as well as virus-only plants of the 980043 genotypes, exhibited severe symptoms, including intense yellowing, extreme leaf twisting, reduced leaf area, and stunted growth. In contrast, T. zelobreve (TZ) and BABA treatments in SB23, and TZ treatment in 980043, showed the least symptom severity, characterized by bright veins with slight vein swelling and leaf crumpling. The incubation period from inoculation to symptom onset varied from 11 to 40 days, depending on genotype and treatment (Table S2, Fig. 1, Fig. S3).
Seed priming significantly increased chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, and total chlorophyll contents compared to non-stressed (Ctrl) and virus-only (V) treatments.
The highest chlorophyll a content was recorded in the BABA-treated 980043genotypes, while the highest chlorophyll b and carotenoid contents were observed in the B. subtilis-treated SB23 genotypes. The lowest pigment contents were found in virus-only treatments of the same genotypes (Table S3, Table 1).
Growth parameters increased upon T. zelobreve, B. subtilis, and BABA treatments.
Fresh and dry weights of shoots and roots were measured at 40 dpi (Tables 2 and 3). B. subtilis treatment resulted in the greatest increase in fresh shoot weight in both genotypes compared to controls. BABA treatment yielded the highest fresh root weight in genotype 980043, whereas B. subtilis treatment resulted in the highest fresh root weight in SB23. Similarly, BABA-treated 980043 plants exhibited the highest shoot and root dry weights. In SB23, the highest root dry weight was observed in B. subtilis-treated plants, whereas the highest shoot dry weight was recorded in TZ-treated plants. Virus-infected plants showed the most pronounced reductions in fresh and dry weights across genotypes.
Figure 1 Effects of seed treatments with Bacillus subtilis (BS), Trichoderma zelobreve (TZ), and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) on symptom severity index (SSI) in two sugar beet genotypes SB23 and 980043, infected with BCTIV, 40 dpi. SSI was scored on a 1–9 scale. Treatments were: inoculated with BCTIV only (V), other treatments, priming agent at the respective concentration + BCTIV. Values are means of 31 replicates ± SE. Bars marked with different letters indicate a significant difference (LSD test, P < 0.05).
Table 1 Effects of Bacillus subtilis (BS), Trichoderma zelobreve (TZ), and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) on chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, total chlorophyll, and carotenoid contents (µg/mL) in sugar beet genotypes inoculated with BCTIV, 40 dpi. Treatments were: inoculated with BCTIV only (V), Control (no priming, non-inoculated), other treatments, priming agent at respective concentrations + BCTIV. For B. subtilis and T. zelobreve, the concentration is expressed in CFU/ml, and in the case of BABA, it is expressed in mM. Data are means of four biological replicates and two technical replicates.
|
Genotypes |
Virus & Priming |
Chlorophyll a (µg/ml) |
Chlorophyll b (µg/ml) |
Total chlorophyll (µg/ml) |
Carotenoid (µg/ml) |
|
980043 |
BS |
5.75 ± 0.252 d |
4.83 ± 0.044 c ϮϮ |
10.58 ± 0.234 b |
4.36 ± 0.047 b |
|
|
BABA 10 mM |
8.91 ± 0.095 a |
4.55 ± 0.042 d |
13.46 ± 0.133 a |
2.45 ± 0.157 e |
|
|
TZ |
4.26 ± 0.125 g |
3.62 ± 0.066 g |
7.88 ± 0.176 e |
3.38 ± 0.153 d |
|
|
Virus |
3.28 ± 0.205 h |
3.36 ± 0.036 h |
6.64 ± 0.194 f |
2.02 ± 0.176 f |
|
|
Control |
7.44 ± 0.129 c |
3.55 ± 0.063 g |
10.99 ± 0.106 b |
2.15 ± 0.08 ef |
|
SB23 |
BS |
7.65 ± 0.096 c |
6.14 ± 0.075 a |
13.79 ± 0.149 a |
5.44 ± 0.068 a |
|
|
BABA 10 mM |
8.21 ± 0.074 b |
5.2 ± 0.055 b |
13.42 ± 0.088 a |
3.61 ± 0.193 cd |
|
|
TZ |
5.33 ± 0.26 de |
4.48 ± 0.076 de |
9.81 ± 0.27 c |
3.98 ± 0.141 c |
|
|
Virus |
4.7 ± 0.169 fg |
3.96 ± 0.085 f |
8.66 ± 0.112 d |
1.95 ± 0.042 f |
|
|
Control |
5.17 ± 0.146 ef |
4.33 ± 0.027 e |
9.5 ± 0.16 c |
3.54 ± 0.128 d |
ϮϮ Means with common letters in each column indicate no significant difference based on the LSD test at the probability of 5%. Values are means ± SE.
Table 2 The effects of genotype, priming agents (Trichoderma zelobreve (TZ), Bacillus subtilis (BS), β-Aminobutyric acid (BABA) and virus on sugar beet growth parameters (shoot and root fresh weight, shoot and root dry weight). Data are means of 10 replicates ± SE. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05). V0: control plants not inoculated with virus; V1: virus-inoculated plants.
|
Genotype |
Priming |
Virus |
Shoot fresh weight |
Root fresh weight |
Shoot dry weight |
Root dry weight |
|
980043 |
BS |
V0 |
5.71 ± 0.111 cd |
0.85 ± 0.018 d ϮϮ |
1.47 ± 0.021 c |
0.31 ± 0.003 cd |
|
|
|
V1 |
5.36 ± 0.138 de |
0.76 ± 0.016 e |
1.39 ± 0.028 d |
0.28 ± 0.009 de |
|
|
BABA 10 mM |
V0 |
5.17 ± 0.13 ef |
0.98 ± 0.014 b |
2.32 ± 0.023 a |
0.5 ± 0.003 a |
|
|
|
V1 |
4.43 ± 0.093 ij |
0.76 ± 0.016 e |
1.37 ± 0.03 d |
0.2 ± 0.001 gh |
|
|
TZ |
V0 |
4.78 ± 0.107 g-i |
0.87 ± 0.021 cd |
1.35 ± 0.026 d |
0.27 ± 0.013 ef |
|
|
|
V1 |
4.58 ± 0.109 ij |
0.66 ± 0.015 f |
1.1 ± 0.026 fg |
0.25 ± 0.017 f |
|
|
Control |
V0 |
4.65 ± 0.114 hi |
0.64 ± 0.021 fg |
0.89 ± 0.023 i |
0.18 ± 0.008 h |
|
|
|
V1 |
4.23 ± 0.062 jk |
0.6 ± 0.015 gh |
0.98 ± 0.025 h |
0.13 ± 0.013 i |
|
SB23 |
BS |
V0 |
6.43 ± 0.209 a |
1.14 ± 0.011 a |
1.33 ± 0.032 d |
0.34 ± 0.012 b |
|
|
|
V1 |
5.77 ± 0.15 bc |
0.92 ± 0.021 c |
1.08 ± 0.028 fg |
0.2 ± 0.004 gh |
|
|
BABA 10 mM |
V0 |
5.66 ± 0.128 cd |
0.9 ± 0.026 cd |
1.25 ± 0.016 e |
0.31 ± 0.005 c |
|
|
|
V1 |
5.07 ± 0.173 e-g |
0.65 ± 0.027 fg |
1.04 ± 0.03 gh |
0.2 ± 0.003 gh |
|
|
TZ |
V0 |
6.1 ± 0.115 ab |
0.78 ± 0.024 e |
1.52 ± 0.02 bc |
0.3 ± 0.003 cd |
|
|
|
V1 |
5.07 ± 0.131 e-g |
0.57 ± 0.016 h |
1.56 ± 0.016 b |
0.25 ± 0.017 f |
|
|
Control |
V0 |
4.96 ± 0.083 f-h |
0.65 ± 0.017 fg |
1.12 ± 0.027 f |
0.2 ± 0.002 g |
|
|
|
V1 |
3.94 ± 0.105 k |
0.61 ± 0.028 f-h |
0.89 ± 0.018 i |
0.2 ± 0 gh |
|
Means with common letters in each column indicate no significant difference based on the LSD test at the probability of 5%. |
||||||
Table 3 The effects of genotype, priming agents (Trichoderma zelobreve (TZ), Bacillus subtilis (BS), β-Aminobutyric Acid (BABA) and virus on sugar beet leaf area index.
|
Genotype |
Prime |
Virus |
Leaf area (cm2) |
|
980043 |
BS |
V0 |
35.67 ± 2.186 ab ϮϮ |
|
|
|
V1 |
31.33 ± 1.333 b |
|
|
BABA 10 mM |
V0 |
37.67 ± 0.333 a |
|
|
|
V1 |
16 ± 1 de |
|
|
TZ |
V0 |
35.67 ± 1.202 ab |
|
|
|
V1 |
25.33 ± 2.028 c |
|
|
Control |
V0 |
14.67 ± 0.882 e |
|
|
|
V1 |
9 ± 0.577 f |
|
SB23 |
BS |
V0 |
35.67 ± 2.333 ab |
|
|
|
V1 |
19.33 ± 0.667 d |
|
|
BABA 10 mM |
V0 |
26 ± 0.577 c |
|
|
|
V1 |
12 ± 1.155 ef |
|
|
TZ |
V0 |
38.33 ± 1.764 a |
|
|
|
V1 |
25.33 ± 3.48 c |
|
|
Control |
V0 |
12.33 ± 0.333 ef |
|
|
|
V1 |
4.33 ± 0.333 g |
Means with common letters in each column indicate no significant difference based on the LSD test at the probability of 5%. Data are means of 10 replicates ± SE.
Seed priming increased leaf greenness and mitigated virus-induced reduction in plant height and leaf area
Genotype, priming, and virus had significant main effects (P < 0.01) on the greenness index, with primed plants showing greater leaf greenness than non-primed controls (Figs. 2, 3, Table S3, S4).
The interaction between genotype and priming was significant for plant height (P < 0.01), whereas the three-way interaction including virus was not significant. Priming treatments generally improved plant height, and some treatments helped maintain better plant growth under viral infection (Figs. 4, 5, Table 3). However, priming effects on leaf area varied by genotype and priming agent. Results of the variance analysis of leaf area are presented in Supplementary Table S5.
Antioxidant enzyme activities in primed plants
The activities of polyphenol oxidase (PPO), peroxidase (POX), and catalase (CAT) were evaluated at 48 hours, 96 hours, and 40 days post-inoculation (dpi) (F) with BCTIV. At all time points, plants treated with B. subtilis, T. zelobreve, and BABA showed significantly higher enzyme activities than untreated virus-infected plants, indicating enhanced activation of the plant antioxidant defense system.
In the 980043 genotype, PPO activity at 48 hours post-inoculation peaked for plants treated with T. zelobreve and B. subtilis, showing no significant differences between these two treatments (Fig. 6). Treated and virus-inoculated plants had significantly greater PPO activity than control plants. In the SB23 genotype, T. zelobreve treatment elicited the highest PPO activity at 48 hours; other priming treatments also showed elevated responses over controls. By 96 hours post-inoculation, PPO activities remained elevated for all primed groups in both genotypes. At 40 dpi (F), PPO activity was highest in treated plants, maintaining the trend of sustained enzyme induction after viral challenge.
POX activity mirrored PPO patterns, with T. zelobreve and B. subtilis treatments eliciting maximal activity in 980043 at 48 hours (Fig. 7). These treatments produced significantly higher POX levels compared to virus-only and control plants. In SB23, T. zelobreve treatment also induced the highest POX activity, with BABA and B. subtilis treatments showing intermediate increases. At 96 hours, primed plants maintained elevated POX activity, whereas virus-infected untreated plants showed a suppressed response, especially in SB23. At 40 dpi (F), POX activity remained significantly higher in primed plants compared to controls in both genotypes.
At 48 hours post-inoculation, T. zelobreve and B. subtilis treatments led to the highest CAT activity in 980043, significantly exceeding virus-only and control plants (Fig. 8). In SB23, BABA treatment induced the most notable CAT activity, while virus-inoculated plants showed a reduced enzymatic response compared to controls. CAT activity peaked at 96 hours in T. zelobreve-treated 980043 plants and remained elevated compared to virus-only treatments. In SB23, T. zelobreve showed superior CAT induction, with virus-infected plants still showing decreased activity. By 40 dpi (F), CAT activity in primed plants continued to exceed that in virus-infected controls, indicating prolonged activation of antioxidant defenses. Variance analysis of enzyme activity is presented in Supplementary Table S6.
Figure 2 Effect of sugar beet genotype on greenness index under Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA): mean changes in greenness index measured under two sugar beet genotypes 980043 and SB23, regardless of priming and virus treatments. Data are means of 10 replicates ± SE. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05).
Figure 3 Effect of seed priming on greenness index across both sugar beet genotypes. Comparison of mean greenness index among different priming treatments (Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and BABA). All priming agents enhanced greenness compared to the non-primed control. Data are means of 10 replicates ± SE. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05).
Figure 4 Effect of BCTIV inoculation on sugar beet plant height under different priming treatments. Comparison of mean plant height under BCTIV-inoculated conditions among various priming treatments and the control group. Primed plants exhibited less reduction in height compared to virus-infected non-primed plants. Data are means of 10 replicates ± SE. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05).
Figure 5 The main effect of virus and seed priming on plant height in sugar beet. Mean plant height measured across different combinations of sugar beet genotypes (980043 and SB23) and priming treatments (Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and BABA). Significant differences were observed among treatments. Data are means of 10replicates ± SE. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05).
The consistent enhancement of PPO, POX, and CAT activities in primed plants across both sugar beet genotypes strongly suggests that B. subtilis, T. zelobreve, and BABA treatments prime the antioxidative defense system to suppress oxidative stress and contribute to resistance mechanisms against BCTIV infection.
Reduced virus accumulation in primed plants
BCTIV accumulation was quantified at 40 days post-inoculation using qPCR with specific primers targeting viral DNA. Relative BCTIV accumulation differed significantly among treatments (P < 0.01). Virus-inoculated control plants had the highest viral DNA levels in both genotypes (Fig. 9). In cultivar 980043, T. zelobreve treatment resulted in the lowest relative BCTIV accumulation and was associated with reduced symptom severity. However, in genotype SB23, B. subtilis showed the lowest virus accumulation among the tested priming treatments, indicating a genotype-dependent response to priming. B. subtilis and BABA treatments also resulted in lower relative viral DNA levels compared with virus-inoculated controls. However, the magnitude of this reduction varied depending on the genotype and the treatment. Overall, priming treatments were associated with reduced BCTIV accumulation at 40 dpi and improved disease outcomes; however, further time-course analyses are required to determine whether these effects result from altered viral replication, delayed infection progression, or restricted systemic movement. A consistent trend was observed between relative BCTIV accumulation and symptom severity, with lower viral DNA levels generally associated with reduced disease symptoms (Table S7, Fig. 9).
Priming efficiency on virus control
The results show that priming sugar beet seeds with B. subtilis, T. zelobreve, and BABA significantly reduced BCTIV-induced symptom severity in both genotypes, 980043 and SB23, compared with non-primed plants (Fig. 1, Table 4). In genotype SB23, T. zelobreve and BABA treatments were associated with greater reductions in disease severity compared with the virus-inoculated control, showing only mild symptoms such as bright veins and slight vein swelling, while the virus-only and B. subtilis-treated plants showed more severe symptoms including intense yellowing, extreme leaf twisting, reduced leaf area, and stunted growth. In genotype 980043, T. zelobreve treatment also markedly reduced symptom severity compared to virus-infected controls.
Figure 6 Effects of Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) on polyphenol oxidase (PPO) (U mg⁻¹ protein) of sugar beet genotypes inoculated with BCTIV 48 and 96 hours post-inoculation and 40 days post-inoculation (F), based on cutting at the Time point. Data are means of four biological replicates and two technical replicates. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05). The data are presented as the mean, with error bars showing standard error (SE).
Figure 7 Effects of Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) on guaiacol peroxidase (POX) (U mg⁻¹ protein) of sugar beet genotypes inoculated with BCTIV 48 and 96 hours post-inoculation and 40 days post-inoculation (F), based on cutting at different time points. Data are means of four biological replicates and two technical replicates. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05). The data are presented as the mean, with error bars showing standard error (SE).
Figure 8 Effects of Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, and β-aminobutyric acid (BABA) on catalase (CAT) (U mg⁻¹ protein) of sugar beet genotypes inoculated with BCTIV 48 and 96hours post-inoculation and fourty days post-inoculation, based on cutting with Time point. Data are means of four biological replicates and two technical replicates. Different letters indicate significant differences (LSD test, P ≤ 0.05). The data are presented as the mean, with error bars showing standard error (SE).
Figure 9 Effect of different treatments on relative BCTIV accumulation in sugar beet plants. Relative BCTIV accumulation was determined at 40 days post-inoculation using qPCR with specific primers targeting viral DNA. Treatments included Bacillus subtilis, Trichoderma zelobreve, BABA, and virus-inoculated controls. The effect of priming treatments on relative BCTIV accumulation varied between genotypes. In genotype 980043, T. zelobreve-treated plants showed the lowest relative BCTIV accumulation, whereas in genotype SB23, B. subtilis-treated plants exhibited the lowest numerical virus accumulation among priming treatments. Virus-inoculated control plants showed the highest relative BCTIV accumulation in both genotypes. Data represent means of four biological replicates with two technical replicates. Different letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (P ≤ 0.05). Error bars represent standard error (SE).
Table 4 Effects of seed priming on disease severity, dry weight and virus accumulation in two sugar beet genotypes (980043 and SB23) 40 days post-inoculation with beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV).
|
Genotype |
Priming agent |
Virus disease control (%) |
Dry weight (% of control) |
Virus accumulation (%) |
|
980043 |
Bacillus subtilis |
75.2 |
90.4 |
32.642 |
|
980043 |
Trichoderma zelobreve |
88.9 |
79.8 |
5.361 |
|
980043 |
BABA |
52.1 |
64.4 |
91.632 |
|
SB23 |
Bacillus subtilis |
11.3 |
75.7 |
45.655 |
|
SB23 |
Trichoderma zelobreve |
45.1 |
75.9 |
53.575 |
|
SB23 |
BABA |
40.8 |
70.2 |
49.076 |
These observations indicate that seed priming with these biological and chemical agents enhances the plants’ resistance to BCTIV infection, likely by stimulating early defense responses that delay symptom onset and reduce symptom intensity. The incubation period from inoculation to symptom appearance varied widely, from 11 to 40 days, reflecting the influence of both genotype and priming treatment on disease symptom progression.
Overall, the data confirm the efficacy of seed priming in controlling BCTIV severity, with T. zelobreve and BABA treatments showing the most pronounced improvements in virus resistance as evidenced by reduced symptom severity indices in both sugar beet genotypes.
Discussion
The study showed that seed priming with biocontrol agents, B. subtilis and T. zelobreve, and BABA increases sugar beet resistance to BCTIV by stimulating growth and activating natural defenses. These results confirm and add to the growing evidence that biopriming and chemical priming are sustainable, environmentally sound strategies for controlling viral diseases in crops (Kumar et al., 2023; Woo et al., 2023).
Conclusion
This study provides strong evidence that treating sugar beet seed with B. subtilis, T. zelobreve, and BABA not only significantly reduces BCTIV severity and accumulation and sugar beet disease but also improves key plant growth and physiological parameters. By explaining the biochemical and physiological mechanisms behind this increased resistance, mainly through activation of key antioxidant enzymes and increased photosynthetic capacity, the study pioneers an integrated, sustainable approach to controlling a virulent disease in a major industrial crop. Responses in specific genotypes further highlight the potential for tailor-made disease management strategies that combine biopriming with host genetic traits to maximize efficacy.
This is a significant step in managing viral diseases, and the findings emphasize the need to promote chemical priming and biopriming as practical, scalable, and environmentally responsible alternatives that reduce chemical pesticide use and support sustainable sugar beet production. This research also addresses an important knowledge gap, as it is the first study to assess these priming methods against BCTIV in sugar beet, which could increase crop tolerance in areas where the disease is a threat, a timely and important finding that can serve as a foundation for translational research and commercial development of new types of biocontrol to protect food security and agricultural sustainability at a large scale.
Acknowledgments
The financial support of Tarbiat Modares University is appreciated.
References
Abdelkhalek, A., Al-Askar, A. A., Arishi, A. A. and Behiry, S. I. 2022. Trichoderma hamatum strain Th23 promotes tomato growth and induces systemic resistance against tobacco mosaic virus. Journal of Fungi, 8: 3.
Baccelli, I. and Mauch-Mani, B. 2016. Beta-aminobutyric acid priming of plant defense: the role of ABA and other hormones. Plant Molecular Biology, 91: 703-711.
Bennett, C. W. 1971. The curly top disease of sugarbeet and other plants. APS, 7: 68-81.
Beris, D., Theologidis, I., Skandalis, N. and Vassilakos, N. 2018. Bacillus amyloliquefaciens strain MBI600 induces salicylic acid dependent resistance in tomato plants against tomato spotted wilt virus and potato virus Y. Scientific Reports, 8: 1.
Desoignies, N., Schramme, F., Ongena, M. and Legrève, A. 2013. Systemic resistance induced by Bacillus lipopeptides in Beta vulgaris reduces infection by the rhizomania disease vector Polymyxa betae. Molecular Plant Pathology, 14: 416-421.
Doyle, J. J. and Doyle, J. D. 1987. A rapid DNA isolation procedure for small quantities of fresh leaf tissue. Phytochemical Bulletin, 19: 11-15.
Etesami, H., Jeong, B. R. and Glick, B. R. 2023. Potential use of Bacillus spp. as an effective biostimulant against abiotic stresses in crops—A review. Current Research in Biotechnology.p. p.
Fatahi, Z., Behjatnia, S. A. A., Afsharifar, A., Hamzehzarghani, H. and Izadpanah, K. 2012. Screening of sugar beet cultivars for resistance to Iranian isolate of beet severe curly top virus using an infectious clone of the virus. Iranian Journal of Plant Pathology, 48: 111-121.
Ghanem, M. and Aqil, H. D. A. 2021. Induction of systemic resistance in tomato plants against tomato leaf curl virus under protected cultivation conditions using a local bacterial isolate of Bacillus subtilis. Arab Journal of Plant Protection, 39: 289-295.
Gibson, K. E. 1967. Possible incidence of curly top in Iran-a new record. Plant Disease Reporter, 51: 976-977.
Grimsley, N., Hohn, B., Hohn, T. and Walden, R. 1986. “Agroinfection,” an alternative route for viral infection of plants by using the Ti plasmid. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 83: 3282-3286.
Guo, Q., Li, Y., Lou, Y., Shi, M., Jiang, Y., Zhou, J., Sun, Y., Xue, Q. and Lai, H. (2019). Bacillus amyloliquefaciens Ba13 induces plant systemic resistance and improves rhizosphere microecology against tomato yellow leaf curl virus disease. Applied Soil Ecology, 137: 154-166.
Hasanvand, V., Kamali, M., Heydarnejad, J., Massumi, H., Kvarnheden, A. and Varsani, A. 2018. Identification of a new turncurtovirus in the leafhopper Circulifer haematoceps and the host plant species Sesamum indicum. Virus Genes, 54: 840-845.
Heydarnejad, J., Hosseini Abhari, E., Bolok Yazdi, H. R. and Massumi, H. 2007. Curly top of cultivated plants and weeds and report of a unique curtovirus from Iran. Journal of Phytopathology, 155: 321-325.
Heydarnejad, J., Keyvani, N., Razavinejad, S., Massumi, H. and Varsani, A. 2013. Fulfilling Koch’s postulates for beet curly top Iran virus and proposal for consideration of new genus in the family Geminiviridae. Archives of Virology, 158(2): 435-443.
Kamali, M., Heydarnejad, J., Massumi, H., Kvarnheden, A., Kraberger, S. and Varsani, A. 2016. Molecular diversity of turncurtoviruses in Iran. Archives of Virology, 161: 551-561.
Kazemi, R., Safaie, N., Atighi, M. R. and Shams-Bakhsh, M. 2026a. Biological and chemical inducers modulate growth and defense mechanisms of tomato against tomato leaf curl Palampur virus. Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology, 141: 103043.
Kazemi, R., Safaie, N., Atighi, M. R. and Shams-Bakhsh, M. 2026b. Microbial and β-aminobutyric acid priming mitigate tomato leaf curl Palampur virus infection in tomato plants through different mechanisms. Scientific Reports, 8: 354-371.
Kazemi, R., Saadati, M., Mokhtasi, A., Pedram, M., Atighi, M. R. and Shams-Bakhsh, M. 2025a. Screening of sugar beet genotypes to beet curly top virus and sugar beet cyst nematode (Heterodera schachtii). Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 27: 1199-1213.
Kazemi, R., Safaie, N., Pedram, M., Atighi, M. R. and Shams-Bakhsh, M. 2025b. Reaction of commercial sugar-beet cultivars to beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV). Journal of Crop Protection, 14: 363-377.
Khazir, H. and Jarjis, M. 2012. Evaluate the efficiency of soaking tomato seed in β-aminobutyric acid and bion to protect tomato plants from tomato mosaic virus infection. Journal of Kerbala University, 30: 1023-1030.
Kumar, K., Pal, G., Verma, A., Kumar, D., Shukla, P. and Verma, S. K. 2023. Seed vectored bacterial endophyte Bacillus pumilus protect sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L.) seedlings from a fungal pathogen Rhizoctonia solani. Biological Control, 183: 105249.
Livak, K. J. and Schmittgen, T. D. 2001. Analysis of relative gene expression data using real-time quantitative PCR and the 2-ΔΔCT method. Methods, 25: 402-408.
Maehly, A. C. and Chance, B. 1954. The assay of catalases and peroxidases. Methods of Biochemical Analysis, 1: 357-424.
Mafakheri, K., Astaraki, S., Safaie, N. and Shams-Bakhsh, M. 2024. Seed bio-/chemo-priming affects the reaction of sugar beet plants to beet curly top virus-Svr. European Journal of Plant Pathology, 169: 473-482.
Mastouri, F., Björkman, T. and Harman, G. E. 2010. Seed treatment with Trichoderma harzianum alleviates biotic, abiotic, and physiological stresses in germinating seeds and seedlings. Phytopathology, 100: 1213-1221.
Meesa, N., Sujipuli, K., Ratanasut, K., Pongcharoen, P., Rungrat, T. and Boonsrangsom, T. 2024. Salicylic acid application against bacterial blight resistance in Xa21-introgression Thai rice cultivar ‘Phitsanulok 2’. Acta Agrobotanica, 77.
Mittler, R. 2002. Oxidative stress, antioxidants and stress tolerance. Trends in Plant Science, 7: 405-410.
Montazeri, R., Shams-Bakhsh, M., Mahmoudi, S. B. and Rajabi, A. 2016. Evaluation of sugar beet lines for resistance to beet curly top viruses. Euphytica, 210: 31-40.
Nazar, R., Iqbal, N., Syeed, S. and Khan, N. A. 2011. Salicylic acid alleviates decreases in photosynthesis under salt stress by enhancing nitrogen and sulfur assimilation and antioxidant metabolism differentially in two mungbean cultivars. Journal of Plant Physiology, 168: 807-815.
Phillips, J. and Hayman, D. S. 1970. Improved procedures for clearing roots and staining parasitic and vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi for rapid assessment of infection. Transactions of the British Mycological Society, 55: 158-161.
Rashid, N. 2014. Effect of soaking seeds in β-aminobutyric acid to induced systemic resistance in zucchini plant against zucchini yellow mosaic virus. Iraqi Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 45: 518-526.
Roumagnac, P., Lett, J. M., Fiallo-Olivé, E., Navas-Castillo, J., Zerbini, F. M., Martin, D. P. and Varsani, A. (2022). Establishment of five new genera in the family Geminiviridae: Citlodavirus, Maldovirus, Mulcrilevirus, Opunvirus, and Topilevirus. Archives of Virology, 167(2), 695-710.
Sedano, M., Lam, N., Escobar, I., Cross, T., Hanson, S. F. and Creamer, R. 2012. Application of vascular puncture for evaluation of curtovirus resistance in chile pepper and tomato. Journal of Phytopathology, 160: 120-128.
Shah, D. A. and Madden, L. V. 2004. Nonparametric analysis of ordinal data in designed factorial experiments. Phytopathology, 94: 33-43.
Siguemoto, É. S. and Gut, J. A. W. 2017. Validation of spectrophotometric microplate methods for polyphenol oxidase and peroxidase activities analysis in fruits and vegetables. Food Science and Technology, 37: 148-153.
Singh, P., Vaishnav, A., Liu, H., Xiong, C., Singh, H. B. and Singh, B. K. 2023. Seed biopriming for sustainable agriculture and ecosystem restoration. Microbial Biotechnology, 16: 2212-2222.
Strausbaugh, C. A., Wintermantel, W. M., Gillen, A. M. and Eujayl, I. A. 2008. Curly top survey in the western United States. Phytopathology, 98: 1212–1217.
Taheri, H., Izadpanah, K. and Behjatnia, S. A. A. 2012. Circulifer haematoceps, the vector of the beet curly top Iran virus. Iranian Journal of Plant Pathology, 48: 45.
Tsotetsi, T., Nephali, L., Malebe, M. and Tugizimana, F. 2022. Bacillus for plant growth promotion and stress resilience: What have we learned? Plants, 11: 2482.
Varsani, A., Martin, D. P., Navas-Castillo, J., Moriones, E., Hernández-Zepeda, C., Idris, A., Zerbini, F. M. and Brown, J. K. (2014). Revisiting the classification of curtoviruses based on genome-wide pairwise identity. Archives of Virology, 159(7), 1873-1882.
Vitti, A., Pellegrini, E., Nali, C., Lovelli, S., Sofo, A., Valerio, M., Scopa, A. and Nuzzaci, M. (2016). Trichoderma harzianum T-22 induces systemic resistance in tomato infected by Cucumber mosaic virus. Frontiers in Plant Science, 7, 1520.
Warren, C. R. 2008. Rapid measurement of chlorophylls with a microplate reader. Journal of Plant Nutrition, 31: 1321-1332.
Woo, S. L., Hermosa, R., Lorito, M. and Monte, E. 2023. Trichoderma: a multipurpose, plant-beneficial microorganism for eco-sustainable agriculture. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 21: 312-326.
Yazdi, H. R. B., Heydarnejad, J. and Massumi, H. 2008. Genome characterization and genetic diversity of beet curly top Iran virus: a geminivirus with a novel nonanucleotide. Archives of Virology, 36: 539-545.
Yıldırım, K., Kavas, M., Kaya, R., Seçgin, Z., Can, C., Sevgen, I., Gökçek Saraç, Ç. and Tahan, V. (2022). Genome-based identification of beet curly top Iran virus infecting sugar beet in Turkey and investigation of its pathogenicity by agroinfection. Journal of Virological Methods, 300, 114380.
تأثیر آمادهباش زیستی و شیمیایی بذر بر افزایش مقاومت چغندرقند به ویروس ایرانی پیچیدگی بوته چغندرقند
مرضیه کوشکی، رویا کاظمی، ناصر صفایی، محمدرضا عتیقی و مسعود شمسبخش*
گروه بیماریشناسی گیاهی، دانشکده کشاورزی، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس، تهران، ایران
پست الکترونیکی نویسنده مسئول مکاتبه: shamsbakhsh@modares.ac.ir
دریافت: 26 اردیبهشت 1405؛ پذیرش: 4 شهریور 1405
چکیده: در این مطالعه تأثیر تیمار بذر ژنوتیپهای چغندرقند با Bacillus subtilis، Trichoderma zelobreve و ماده شیمیایی β- آمینوبوتیریک اسید (BABA) را بر رشد، ویژگیهای فیزیولوژیک و پاسخ به آلودگی به ویروس پیچیدگی برگ چغندر ایران (BCTIV; Becurtovirus betae) بررسی شد. دو ژنوتیپ چغندرقند SB23 و 980043 تحت تیمار پرایمینگ میکروبی و شیمیایی با BABA قرار گرفت و سپس در شرایط گلخانه از طریق آگرواینوکولیشن با ویروس مایهزنی شدند. نتایج نشان داد که شدت علائم بیماری و میزان تجمع ویروس در گیاهان تیمار شده در مقایسه با گیاهان شاهد (آلوده بدون پرایمینگ)، بهطور معنیداری کمتر بود. همچنین شاخصهای رشد شامل وزن تر و خشک اندام هوایی و ریشه، میزان کلروفیل و کاروتنوئید، شاخص سطح برگ و ارتفاع گیاه در گیاهان تیمار شده افزایش یافت. فعالیت آنزیمهای آنتیاکسیدانی شامل پلیفنلاکسیداز، پراکسیداز و کاتالاز پس از تیمار افزایش پیدا کرد که نشاندهنده فعال شدن سیستم دفاعی گیاه است. این تیمارها با افزایش مقاومت، اثرات مخرب BCTIV را کاهش داده و این مقاومت با افزایش پاسخهای بیوشیمیایی دفاعی و بهبود وضعیت فیزیولوژیک گیاه همراه بود. این یافتهها نشان میدهد که تیمار بذر با B. subtilis، T. zelobreve و BABA باعث بهبود رشد چغندرقند و القای مقاومت سیستمیک به BCTIV میشود و میتواند راهکاری امیدبخش و پایدار برای مدیریت این بیماری در مناطق آلوده باشد.
واژگان کلیدی: تجمع ویروس، فعالیت آنزیمهای دفاعی، آمادهباش بذری، پیسیآر کمی
Supplementary tables and figures
Table S1 Primer pairs used in this study.
|
Primers name |
Sequences (5’à3’) |
Product size (bp) |
Function |
Reference |
|
DNA-BCTIV Forward |
CGCATCCCTCCTAATCCGAT |
127bp |
Amplification of DNA of the virus |
Kazemi et al., 2025 |
|
DNA- CTIV Reverse |
TGGCTAGTGGTGCATTTTGG |
|
||
|
SSU DNA B.Vulgaris Forward |
CGTTCTTAGTTGGTGGAGCG |
245bp |
Reference gene |
Kazemi et al., 2025 |
|
SSU DNA B.vulgaris Reverse |
AAGATTACCCGGACCTGTCG |
|
Figure S1 View of rhizospheric soil culture around the root of sugar beet treated with: A) Bacillus subtilis and B) Trichoderma zelobreve.
|
|
Figure S2 Pattern of sugar beet root colonization by Trichoderma zelobreve: Hyphae of T. zelobreve have penetrated the roots and grown in the intercellular spaces of the root epidermis.
Table S2 Mean Squares of the effect of cultivar and priming on Symptome severity index.
|
S. V. |
df |
Score |
|
Cultivar (C) |
1 |
117.18 ** |
|
Priming (P) |
3 |
44.98 ** |
|
C × P |
3 |
15.15 ×* |
|
Error |
72 |
0.382 |
|
CV (%) |
|
10.18 |
** significant at 1 percent probability levels.
|
A |
Figure S3 Sugar beet plants inoculated with beet curly top Iran virus (BCTIV), showing typical viral symptoms including reduced plant growth, leaf curling, and vein swelling. A: Trichoderma zelobreve treatment showing milder symptoms, including slight vein swelling and moderate leaf curling. B: Control treatment (virus-inoculated, untreated) exhibiting severe symptoms such as pronounced vein swelling and extensive leaf curling.
Table S3 Mean Squares of the effect of cultivar and prime on photosynthetic pigments (chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, total chlorophyll, and carotenoid) of sugar beet.
|
S. V. |
df |
Chlorophyll a |
Chlorophyll b |
Total Chlorophyll |
Carotenoid |
|
Cultivar (C) |
1 |
0.808 ** |
7.064 ** |
12.65 ** |
6.88 ** |
|
Prime (P) |
4 |
25.23 ** |
4.57 ** |
44.80 ** |
9.44 ** |
|
C × P |
4 |
6.008 ×* |
0.159 ** |
6.99 ** |
0.67 ** |
|
Error |
30 |
0.111 |
0.014 |
0.117 |
0.067 |
|
CV (%) |
|
5.50 |
2.71 |
3.27 |
7.88 |
*. ** Significant at the 5 and 1 percent probability levels. Respectively.
Table S4 Mean Squares of the effect of cultivar, prime and virus on greenness index (SPAD), plant height and fresh and dry weight of shoots and roots.
|
S. V. |
df |
SPAD |
Plant height |
Fresh weight of aerial parts |
Root fresh weight |
Dry weight of aerial parts |
Root dry weight |
Total fresh weight |
Total dry weight |
|
Cultivar (C) |
1 |
1621.80 ** |
19.60 ** |
10.44 ** |
0.007 ns |
0.73 ** |
0.009 ** |
5.65 ** |
0.0002 ns |
|
Prime (P) |
3 |
153.47 ** |
5.78 ** |
12.57 ** |
0.645 ** |
2.03 ** |
0.122 ** |
20.70 ** |
1.22 ** |
|
Virus (V) |
1 |
296.48 ** |
8.10 ** |
15.66 ** |
1.053 ** |
2.17 ** |
0.306 ** |
29.50 ** |
2.49 ** |
|
C × P |
3 |
21.86 ns |
3.60 ** |
1.36 ** |
0.226 ** |
1.89 ** |
0.041 ** |
3.52 ** |
0.29 ** |
|
C × V |
1 |
1.93 ns |
0.025 ns |
1.57 ** |
0.016 * |
0.184 ** |
0.006 ** |
0.68 * |
0.002 ns |
|
P × V |
3 |
11.43 ns |
0.212 ns |
0.083 ns |
0.073 ** |
0.557 ** |
0.070 ** |
0.70 ** |
0.234 ** |
|
C × P × V |
3 |
3.23 ns |
0.396 ns |
0.45 * |
0.011 * |
0.579 ** |
0.042 ** |
1.58 ** |
0.077 ** |
|
Error |
144 |
8.63 |
0.248 |
0.161 |
0.004 |
0.006 |
0.0008 |
0.168 |
0.004 |
|
CV (%) |
|
7.92 |
15.88 |
7.84 |
8.09 |
6.07 |
10.92 |
6.40 |
6.57 |
ns, *, ** non-significant and significant at the 5 and 1 percent probability levels, respectively.
Table S5 Mean Squares of the effect of cultivar, prime and virus on leaf area (LA) of sugar beet.
|
S. V. |
df |
LA |
|
Cultivar (C) |
1 |
192.00 ** |
|
Prime (P) |
3 |
1152.05 ** |
|
Virus (V) |
1 |
1633.33 ** |
|
C × P |
3 |
47.40 ** |
|
C × V |
1 |
16.33 ns |
|
P × V |
3 |
63.17 ** |
|
C × P × V |
3 |
48.40 ** |
|
Error |
32 |
7.00 |
|
CV (%) |
|
11.18 |
ns ** non- significant and significant at 1 percent probability levels, respectively.
Table S6 Mean Squares of the effect of cultivar, prime, and virus on the activity of defense enzymes in sugar beet.
|
S. V. |
df |
PPO |
PER |
CAT |
|
Time (T) |
3 |
0.0015 ** |
0.060 ** |
0.0013 ** |
|
Timepoint (TM) |
2 |
0.033 ** |
0.028 ** |
0.0002 ** |
|
Cultivar (C) |
1 |
0.000012 ns |
0.053 ** |
0.0013 ** |
|
Virus& Prime (VP) |
4 |
0.010 ** |
0.052 ** |
0.00045 ** |
|
T × TM |
6 |
0.0055 ** |
0.0021 ** |
0.0005 ** |
|
T × C |
3 |
0.0026 ** |
0.006 ** |
0.0003 ** |
|
TM × C |
2 |
0.142 ** |
0.084 ** |
0.005 ** |
|
T × TM × C |
6 |
0.1 ** |
0.0053 ** |
0.00032 ** |
|
T × VP |
12 |
0.1 ** |
0.008 ** |
0.00087 ** |
|
TM × VP |
8 |
0.042 ** |
0.057 ** |
0.0043 ** |
|
C × VP |
4 |
0.016 ** |
0.072 ** |
0.0007 ** |
|
T × TM × VP |
24 |
0.012 ** |
0.015 ** |
0.0007 ** |
|
T × C × VP |
12 |
0.011 ** |
0.016 ** |
0.0013 ** |
|
TM × C × VP |
8 |
0.049 |
0.07 ** |
0.003 ** |
|
T × TM × C × VP |
24 |
0.008 ** |
0.009 ** |
0.0008 ** |
|
Error |
360 |
0.00032 |
0.0005 |
0.000011 |
|
CV (%) |
|
10.62 |
11.15 |
6.97 |
ns. ** Non-significant and significant at 1 percent probability levels. Respectively.
Table S7 Mean Squares of Table of RT-PCR Data.
|
S. V. |
df |
Virus accumulation |
|
Cultivar (C) |
1 |
0.032 ** |
|
Priming + virus (PV) |
3 |
1.02 ** |
|
C × PV |
3 |
0.279 ** |
|
Error |
24 |
0.002 |
|
CV (%) |
|
7.49 |
** Significant at the 1 percent probability level.
*Corresponding authors: shamsbakhsh@modares.ac.ir
Received: 16 May 2026, Accepted: 26 August 2026
Published online: 17 November 2026